A few of our stories and columns are now in front of the paywall. We at The Chief remain committed to independent reporting on labor and civil service. It's been our mission since 1897. You can have a hand in ensuring that our reporting remains relevant in the decades to come. Consider supporting The Chief, which you can do for as little as $3.20 a month.
The Chief’s Nov. 10 report, “Dispute over healthcare savings scrambles DC 37 contract negotiations,” raises a question union leaders must answer: Why must the conversation about fair wages begin with healthcare concessions?
And why is the failed attempt to force retirees into Medicare Advantage still being presented as a lost opportunity?
Active employees deserve substantial raises and quality healthcare. Retirees deserve the healthcare security they earned through decades of public service.
Union leaders should be fighting for both.
Instead, Kevin Sullivan, a member of the Municipal Labor Committee’s technical committee and former administrator of the Uniformed Fire Officers Association’s welfare funds, describes the abandoned Medicare Advantage conversion as “a real savings loss.”
For retirees, that proposal put something far more consequential at risk: access to trusted doctors, hospitals and prescribed care.
This proposal put retirees’ lives at risk. In my world, that is not savings.
We were defending our healthcare. We should not be blamed for refusing to surrender it.
The projected $600 million in annual savings also deserves more scrutiny than the phrase “Medicare Advantage hole” allows. Where would that money have gone, and would it have solved the underlying problem?
In January 2023, the Independent Budget Office explained that the city planned to direct the entire savings to the off-budget Health Insurance Stabilization Fund.
Former City Comptroller Brad Lander's December 2025 audit subsequently found that the Office of Labor Relations and the MLC authorized transfers and payments inconsistent with the fund’s purposes. It also found that the anticipated Medicare Advantage “savings” would not have kept the fund solvent, and they knew it from the start.
That is a failure of financial stewardship.
Retirees did not create the problem by defending their coverage. They did.
District Council 37 Executive Director Henry Garrido says he wants to prevent members from paying more for healthcare. Retirees judge that assurance against the healthcare savings agreements he supported, and the costs retirees have faced.
When an expense moves from the city’s budget to a retiree’s pocket, calling it “savings” conceals who is paying. He owes members an accounting of those costs before asking them to trust another deal.
Garrido's role in recent MLC agreements and his two unsuccessful bids to lead the MLC have done nothing to restore our confidence and continue to erode our trust. Credibility must be earned through transparency and results, not another round of false assurances.
Twice he was part of forcing retirees into Medicare Advantage and implementing copays for the first time in 60 years, leaving retirees suing the city for five years to defend their benefits and pension dollars.
We will do it again if needed.
The attack on retired public service labor didn’t end there. When retirees had legislation introduced at the city and state levels to protect retirees’ healthcare from being diminished in retirement, the two largest unions, New York State AFL-CIO and American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, literally lobbied against it, including this year.
Garrido and the MLC must answer for the agreements they negotiated. Retirees are no longer members of the active bargaining units. We do not vote to ratify their contracts, and retirees cannot vote in DC 37 elections.
Yet they used our healthcare as part of their “savings” commitments.
We did not make those deals. We should not be handed the bill.
The Chief reports that Garrido has offered to shift an estimated $109 million in annual PICA prescription-drug costs from the city to DC 37 and its welfare funds to help secure larger raises.
Members deserve to know precisely how that would work. Would the transfer be fully supported by lower drug costs? What happens if projected savings fall short? Would other welfare-fund benefits face pressure? Could members eventually face higher costs?
The article does not establish that this proposal would cut benefits. But members shouldn't be expected to accept an assurance without seeing the terms and numbers behind them. After the Medicare Advantage and NYCE PPO agreements—with hundreds of pages redacted—members deserve full disclosure before being asked to approve another deal.
Garrido says he wants to protect healthcare access and prevent members from paying more. Members should hold him to that commitment, as we have seen no evidence so far. Assurances alone are not enough.
A raise buys less when higher healthcare expenses consume it. Bargaining gains must be measured against the costs workers will actually bear and the retirement protections they may give up.
Union leaders should challenge the premise that wage increases require healthcare concessions. They should scrutinize provider prices, insurer charges and administrative expenses, and demand an honest accounting of the city’s obligations.
They must also answer plainly: Are retiree benefits being discussed in these negotiations? Is another Medicare Advantage proposal under consideration, as we are told a deputy mayor has already inquired? What commitments are being made, and who would bear their cost?
The article’s rank-and-file voices offer the right principle: Workers should have a meaningful opportunity to approve healthcare agreements, rather than discover their consequences afterward. MLC discussions must be shared with union boards and members, not kept secret.
Before ratification, members should demand the full proposed contract and every incorporated healthcare agreement. A summary is no substitute for the terms that will govern your benefits.
Ask what premium-free coverage includes, what other costs may change, and what happens when you retire.
Today’s active worker is tomorrow’s retiree. The healthcare security you allow leaders to trade away now may be your own.
I learned unionism as a commitment to protect workers throughout their lives. That commitment should not expire when they leave the payroll.
Retirees are organized, and we will keep fighting to protect our healthcare. Our former unions should be standing beside us.
And current union members should pay attention: If your leaders can bargain away our healthcare today when we have no seat at that table, yours will be next. When you retire, you may find yourselves carrying the same torch, unless we all act together now!
You are union leaders. Fight like it.
Fair wages and secure healthcare belong on the same side of the bargaining table.
4 comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here
Great article by our Leader, Marianne!! It is long overdue for the MLC and its member unions and Locals to get behind her and the Retirees Organization. Having a high-quality Civil Service - Police Officers, Teachers and EMTs' who are properly compensated and whose benefits are secure, is very much in the City's real interests.
3 days ago Report this
corodriguez2000
Garrido and Mulgrew have proven that self interest. Their huge salaries and benefits matter more to them than protecting retirees healthcare. Getting bigger salaries for active members ensures they keep their cushy jobs. It sickening to see so many union presidents on the MLC going along with these contracts. I took a city correction job for a pension and great medical benefits. Now I look at these new presidents as they give away everything I worked for with disgust. A retired correction officer.
3 days ago Report this
DOTHERIGHTTHING
Why is Kevin Sullivan, a member of the Municipal Labor Committee’s technical committee and former administrator of the Uniformed Fire Officers Association’s welfare funds still even talking about Medicare Advantage Plans? It sells out NYC Medicare Retirees earned Healthcare since it is not Medicare, has no advantages, & does not achieve the savings proposed on Retirees Backs .
Even the UFOA voted no when the second MAP was proposed.
When is NYC,NYC COUNCIL, & The Unions going to stop the betrayal of NYC Medicare Retirees & stop blocking Intro Bill 1008 to protect NYC Medicare Retirees Earned Healthcare. Shame on them ALL!
3 days ago Report this
thePuma
My father retired from FDNY early 60's. Pay and benefits back then were not enough for him to support his large family, and he always had other side jobs to keep up, so he began a second career in the private sector. Since then, city unions made strides negotiating decent contracts. One of the primary aspects of which were the tradeoff of lower wage increases in lieu of better retirement and health benefits. Those benefits became the primary enticement and value to taking those civil SERVICE jobs since. Long term security over the immediate gain. This was why 24 years after he retired from FDNY I decided it was a worthwhile pursuit to take a civil SERVICE job myself.
Throughout my career, over many contracts negotiated, there was the assurance I could depend on reliable no cost healthcare benefits into my later years. Now I am seeing the rug getting pulled out from under that security by entities that have no right to do so and are also doing so at the long-term harm to those they represent.
I worked under a contract that provided benefits which I never signed away. By denying me those benefits now is a retroactive BREACH OF CONTRACT. Will the powers that be running the City of New York, my former employer and a party to those contracts, now reimburse me with interest value added for all the former wages I have forgone over my career to compensate? I know and you all know the answer to that question. There was a calculated decision made again and again by the City in those contract negotiations over the last 50 years or more. Savings for them they could invest elsewhere for greater return. Now that the bill they avoided then is still due and they failed to put the savings into savings for those future costs they want to renege on those contracts and promises made at my (our) expense. Simply wrong no matter how you look at it or how it's presented.
3 days ago Report this