Log in Subscribe

A few of our stories and columns are now in front of the paywall. We at The Chief remain committed to independent reporting on labor and civil service. It's been our mission since 1897. You can have a hand in ensuring that our reporting remains relevant in the decades to come. Consider supporting The Chief, which you can do for as little as $3.20 a month.

Allies or infiltrators? Socialists affirm 'above and below' union strategy

NYC-DSA seeks collaboration with "progressive" unions

Posted

They are a specter that's haunting workplaces across the city, marching with striking workers on picket lines, canvassing in support of pro-union bills and, as of this year, infiltrated City Hall itself.  

As members of the Democratic Socialists of America have matured the New York City chapter's political operation and grown in numbers over the last half-decade, the organization has forged closer relationships with unions in the city.

This year, NYC-DSA joined with the New York State Nurses Association, the Communication Workers of America, the Professional Staff Congress of CUNY, United Auto Workers Region 9A, the New York Taxi Workers Alliance and more to push Governor Kathy Hochul to approve higher taxes on wealthy New Yorkers.  And the group has had an active, ongoing collaboration with Teamsters Local 804 to pass the Delivery Protection Act, a pro-worker bill sponsored by DSA member Tiffany Caban, through the City Council. 

That collaboration is the background of a resolution passed by delegates to the NYC-DSA convention over the weekend calling for the organization to orient itself towards building a "mass labor-left movement" in the city. The resolution affirmed that the group would push to recruit unionists for political office, advocate for initiatives on the city and state level that empower workers and continue its rank-and-file organizing campaign to encourage members to join unions and those already in unions to become "activist" union members.

'Not as something we infiltrate, but as something we build'

Nina Bruckenthal, one of the resolution's authors and a member of the United Federation of Teachers, said the resolution orients the organization toward building on its "above and below" labor strategy – encouraging members to join unions and organize within them for change from the bottom-up, while boosting top-level collaboration between union leadership and the DSA over shared priorities.  

But that strategy, particularly the bottom-up aspect, has elicited discontent from union leaders in the past. A 2019 Politico article tracking DSA's push to "take over" ten of the city's unions has haunted DSA's labor-oriented organizers and helped the organization earn a reputation as a group that seeds unions with carpetbagging infiltrators and rank-and-file agitators. 

NYC-DSA and its candidates are still held at an arm's length by some large establishment unions.

Many unions endorsed candidates opposing Mayor Zohran Mamdani, a DSA member, when he ran in the Democratic Party primary in 2025, just as many unions did for the primary elections of representatives-elect Claire Valdez and Darializa Avila Chevalier, both former union members and current DSA members. 

Bruckenthal insists DSA has worked tirelessly since 2019 to overcome its reputation, and has built collaborative relationships with union leadership. 

"DSA has been able to demonstrate its commitment to the labor movement not as something we infiltrate, but as something we build," she said. "DSA members are committed to building the labor movement wherever they are – on the picket line, in the workplace, in Albany. DSA members are committed to that arena as an area to fight in." 

Collaboration with Teamsters

The "above" strategy, said Bruckenthal and Matt Maresca, a union organizer and co-author of the resolution, is best shown in DSA's campaign with the Teamsters to pass the first-in-the-nation Delivery Protection Act that would force Amazon to directly employ its delivery drivers.

NYC-DSA passed two other labor-related resolutions by consent agenda (a governance tool that allows organizations to pass non-controversial measures without a tallied vote) one of which focuses directly on taking on Amazon. 

DSA has been a "key collaborator" in pushing for the DPA, said Josh Pomeranz, the operations director of Teamsters Local 804. 

"In terms of DSA's ability to mobilize community members, particularly with the canvasses they've done, the value of that has been really felt," he said. "When everybody's interests align, I think it's very useful." 

It's the type of collaboration from above DSA hopes to achieve with other unions.  

"We're looking forward to finding more ways to collaborate with unions on more ventures in the future," said Marcesa. "It’s important we cultivate close ties with progressive unions in New York." 

DSAers agitate for change within unions

But the "progressive" moniker, in practice, tends to exclude powerful public-sector unions like the United Federation of Teachers and District Council 37, two of the 10 unions reportedly on the 2019 takeover list.

It is inside those two unions, which together represent more than two-thirds of the city's public-sector employees, where DSA members have most notably agitated for turnover of union leadership. The UFT's insurgent Movement of Rank-and-File Educators (MORE) caucus includes many DSA members, including Bruckenthal, and DSA members have been at the forefront of challenging and ousting incumbents in several DC 37 locals.  

"Personally, as a rank-and-file union member I want to build my union into a fighting vehicle," Bruckenthal said. "I want to organize with my coworkers to do that." 

This month, DSA members are running for leadership of two more DC 37 locals, Health Care Employees Local 768 and Local 375, the Civil Service Technical Guild that together represent almost 10,000 city workers.

But the NYC-DSA as a whole is not involved in those races, and is treading lightly with regard to internal union battles. The resolution passed over the weekend contains a clause affirming that the organization "not direct internal organizing or take organizational positions on internal union political matters." 

Marcesa insisted that, when it comes to internal union politics, the role of DSA is to "foster a community of DSA members who are working in different sectors," instead of taking positions on internal union fights.  

Beyond the internal organizing of individual DSA members, the organization also backs the Rank And File Project that recruits young activist workers to join existing unions and reform them.  "We aim to turn the unions we join into strong, militant, democratic organizations that can win major gains for workers, by workers," the group's website reads.  

DSA also backs the Emergency Workplace Organizing Committee, in partnership United Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers of America, that offers support and training to workers seeking to organize.

"Once our growth came about, and unions saw that we were partners, we really found that we shared a lot of goals, and it's really been fruitful to build towards those goals together," Marcesa said. "We want to work with any union that is interested in passing legislation and waging campaigns that boost labor power in New York City and New York State."

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here