Log in Subscribe

A few of our stories and columns are now in front of the paywall. We at The Chief remain committed to independent reporting on labor and civil service. It's been our mission since 1897. You can have a hand in ensuring that our reporting remains relevant in the decades to come. Consider supporting The Chief, which you can do for as little as $3.20 a month.

The impractical dream

Posted

To the editor:

To tax wealth is to catch the wind. It is a failed policy.

The crown sees the fruit of honest labor and envisions a captive pride. It ravishes the tree by stealing its yield, blind to the truth that wealth has large wings; when they are forcefully clipped, the bird yelps and flies to more fruitful realms.

The past, like the human tongue, speaks harshly. Rulers have tried to force all men to be equal, yet that defies the laws of nature.

They stripped the prosperous by decreeing unjust edicts, bringing a deep blight upon the landscape. Brilliant minds fled. Gold crossed the vast sea to welcoming shores.

The myopic state was lost in a self-inflicted maze, expending its strength to catch a ghost, causing the law to die a shameful death.

To crush the prize of initiative is to stifle the seed of growth. It is a falsehood, an impractical dream.

The magistrates think they can fill the stream by drawing the waters that sustain its vitality. When you drain the life-giving waters from the earth, you leave a parched and dry land. You leave the world in a state of misery, for a state that steals the soul to line its coffers with gold will rule a dry and barren kingdom.

Robert Sica

Comments

16 comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here

  • Admin

    Meaningless rhetoric without facts. In fact, taxing the rich worked very well in the 1950s, a decade where workers earned a lot more than today in terms of real money.

    Wednesday, October 28 Report this

  • reenjoe

    The rich have never left the countries that made them rich. Human migration has always been comprised of the poor and downtrodden. This "essay" is complete nonsense.

    Wednesday, October 28 Report this

  • Valete

    Check your facts! I’ll give you a hint. The modern Nordic countries repealed the wealth tax with the exception of one, Norway.

    Wednesday, October 28 Report this

  • reenjoe

    Here's a fact - Sam Brownback's 2012 Kansas Experiment which lowered top-end taxes bankrupted the state. GOP legislators overthrow the tax cuts in 2017, by a 2/3rds majority, because the cuts produced no growth and massive debt.

    BTW, billionaire lobbies spent a fortune getting Nordic and other European countries to remove their wealth taxes. Retirees, pensioners and Civil Servants all regret the decision to end wealth taxes.

    Wednesday, October 28 Report this

  • krell1349

    I am sorry, but the rich don't pay their fair share of taxes. They should be taxed more. I pay more taxes than some of these rich folks.

    Thursday, October 29 Report this

  • Valete

    To add poetic structure to an otherwise boring subject is necessary to overcome the laborious and mechanical letters and posts that blanket the majority of pages by letter writers of conventional prose. Thus, my poem is in narrative form to prove the fallacies of the posts herein.

    Upon the dim track, one last truth abides, writ in the holy scroll of wild tides: a host of those who scraped gold in the deep dales of Norway have packed their dark tents and fled. They have gone to the high hills of Switzerland and other small bields, leaving the kind dirt the hour the grim hand of the king asked a great share of their store. This is a stone heap of fact, standing fast against the frail winds of deceit.

    Yet, a gray shade falls upon the breast when we see this swift flight. It brings a sharp woe to see the great turning their backs upon the very mother land that fed their hid seeds and made them grand. In their quick flight, the proud words of old turn to dust. Does this not break the weak cup of your lore? Does it not still each vain word you speak on the tale, proving that even the tall trees will leave the earth that fed them when frost grows too keen?

    Thursday, October 29 Report this

  • namrogm

    To Valete, Word Man, Robert Sica, etc:

    “Alas, poor Yorick, (Valete), I knew him; he was such a bore.”

    Monday, November 2 Report this

  • krell1349

    Valete, your post makes no sense and does not contribute to the discussion.

    Tuesday, November 3 Report this

  • reenjoe

    More sophistry from the man of many names, the latest being Valete (aka Robert Sica).

    Anyone who places their greed over their country is welcomed to leave with their ill-gotten gains. No nation needs people who put their purse above their patriotism, even if they are billionaires.

    Tuesday, November 3 Report this

  • Valete

    When do the socialists and communists leave for the hinterlands?

    Tuesday, November 3 Report this

  • Valete

    I write this post in clear prose. There is no doubt on my stance. The wealth tax failed.

    Time proves it.

    The tax brings lost cash. It makes high cost. It lowers tax yield. In old days, twelve lands tried a wealth tax. Now, most dropped it. They lost gold.

    Rich folks move fast. They have choice. Heavy tax makes them leave. They flee to free lands.

    The same truth holds for high rates on pay.

    Past the war, rates were past ten tens. This killed long investment. So JFK brought new law. It cut the top rate down to seven tens. Growth went up.

    High tax rates kill capital funds. It does not fill the vault. Wealth lore is a soft art. Rules must be wise. If not, the economy will crash. It will hit a burst or worse.

    All pen names me boy!

    Tuesday, November 3 Report this

  • reenjoe

    More twaddle from Sica, friend of the rich and enemy of the working man. The 1950s saw the fastest economic expansion in US history with GDP growth over 4 percent per year WITH a top tax rate over 90 percent. The 1960s had similar growth with a 70 percent top rate as LBJ's War on Poverty invested heavily in working class citizens.

    Since Nixon ended LBJ's War on Poverty investments and Reagan implemented his failed trickle down, low tax policies, GDP growth has struggled to exceed 2 percent per year. Trickle down has also led to the two worst US recessions, in 1987 & 2007, and an ever growing $40 trillion debt.

    If the world's billionaires had to pay a 5 percent wealth tax, they wouldn't even notice. They would still be fabulously rich and the economy would most likely improve.

    Tuesday, November 3 Report this

  • krell1349

    Valete = Word Man. Now see what happened to your party. A tsunami. The House and the Senate!! People are tired of MAGA and Trump lies. The end of Trumpism is coming next. Maybe the rich will be taxed now!!!!

    Wednesday, November 4 Report this

  • Valete

    Above the Roar

    Dust rises from the sidewalks where he began his climb.

    Old shadows followed in his fight against Father Time.

    No room was silent when he spoke above the roar,

    And every rally echoed like waves upon the shore.

    Loud voices shook the rafters from land to shining sea.

    Deep lines formed in history for the world to see.

    Tough fights beset him daily, yet he chose to tread.

    Rough winds blew to no end, but he forged ahead.

    Under bright, flashing cameras, he stood to make his claim.

    Men cheered; flags waved as they shouted his name.

    Pride filled the great halls, for they gave him full acclaim.

    4 days ago Report this

  • Valete

    What happened in the midterm elections is par for the course; check hist

    4 days ago Report this

  • Valete

    Don’t Believe the Hype: Why the 2026 "Midterm Curse" Isn't Game Over for Trump

    To put the midterm elections in perspective, I’ll whisper a little secret about the longstanding "midterm curse" facing the sitting president’s party. It’s a historical fact that from 1934 to 2022, the president’s party lost an average of 27 House seats and 3.4 Senate seats in the midterms. The record-holders of that curse in modern history? FDR and Obama. FDR lost 72 House seats in 1938, and Obama lost 63 House seats in 2010—the biggest House flips since 1934. So, don’t get all revved up about these 2026 midterm elections. Quite frankly, Trump still holds the trump card: the veto. And sure, the House can impeach, but the Democrats can’t do one thing to actually remove Trump from office. Why? Because they don’t have a two-thirds majority in the Senate. Have a good day guys!

    4 days ago Report this