Hundreds of former and current home-care workers and their allies rallied last week outside the state Division of Labor Standards in downtown Brooklyn to demand an end to the notorious 24-hour workday and to recoup the wages they say they are owed.
The notorious practice assigns home-care workers to the home of a patient who needs around-the-clock care but for which they are paid for just 13 hours, with the other 11 hours, ostensibly catalogued as time for sleep and meals, unpaid.
Despite nearly a decade of court battles and activism, several home-care agencies in New York continue to employ the practice, among them the Chinese-American Planning Council, First Chinese Presbyterian Community Affairs Home Attendant Corp., Premier Home Health Care, American Business Institute and Royal Care, the rally-goers said. That led city Comptroller Brad Lander’s office to find that the home-care industry had the most wage theft violations in 2024.
Some home-care companies have been particularly egregious in how they employ the 24-hour workday and then deny wages. According to advocates, the Chinese-American Planning Council is responsible for $90 million in stolen wages from unpaid hours.
And recourse for the workers, when it is available to them, has been frustrating at best. Starting in April 2023, the Department of Labor quietly closed more than 100 cases of wage theft that had been under investigation since 2018. In letters to the workers, the department said that there were other means besides those at the DOL to resolve their claims.
One former home-care worker with the CPC whose case was suddenly closed, Gui Zhu Chen, demanded answers.
“For eight years, I was waking up seven to eight times, for several hours throughout the night to care for my patient,” she said. “After speaking with the CPC several times about the issue, they fired me, which forced me into retirement. I initially had two cases opened — one for wage theft and one for retaliation. I’m here to demand Governor Hochul enforce labor law.”
Some blame governor
In a 100-page policy report, David A. Lee, a former legislative director for Queens Assembly Member Ron Kim, scrupulously detailed efforts by the Chinese-American Planning Council to use legal tactics to evade cornerstone labor laws.
“To willfully dismiss and ignore capital’s deceptive and powerfully strategic tactics by way of the law is to remain intentionally blind to the surplus of ways in which capital has incapacitated all of us,” Lee wrote. “The law is anything but abstract — it is often the primary weapon by capitalists for determining the material condition of working peoples everywhere.”
Many of the roughly 500 workers and former workers at the Oct. 8 rally held signs, reading “NYS DOL = Department of Lies! NYS DOL CLOSED WAGE THEFT CASES” and “GOVERNOR HOCHUL! ENFORCE LABOR LAW NOW.”
The workers and their advocates say the home-care companies have consistently violated several laws and regulations, including the Wage Theft Prevention Act, the Minimum Wage Act, the DOL's Minimum Wage Orders and the Fair Labor Standards Act, which requires all employers at the state and federal level to extensively report all working hours and corresponding rates of pay.
State law also requires that any home-care agency receiving Medicaid reimbursement — such as the CPC, among other agencies — must be in strict compliance with the Home Care Worker Wage Parity Act, which also requires full compensation of all working hours.
In the last year, Hochul has been criticized for renewing Medicaid contracts with several home-care agencies, including the CPC. Combined with the sudden closings of wage-theft cases in the DOL, these Medicaid contracts reveal a consistent pattern of ignoring workers’ grievances with the CPC and other home-care agencies, advocates say. They also claim that the governor has helped shield home-care agencies from prosecution for their labor-law violations.
“We have some of the strongest wage-theft laws in the nation,” Kim, the Queens Assembly member, said at the rally. “But when it comes to enforcing that law, [Hochul] says ‘Oh, I have a friend here, I have a friend there. I’m not going to enforce that law for you. Please go look the other way.’”
Downtown Manhattan City Council Member Christopher Marte, a longstanding advocate for ending the 24-hour workday, has advocated splitting the around-the-clock shifts into two 12-hour tours.
“Justice delayed is justice denied,” Marte said at the rally. “So allow the courts, allow the Department of Labor to do its job.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here