Log in Subscribe

Legal Aid attorneys 'upset' with tentative agreement, urge 'no' vote

Say union negotiators 'missed the moment'

Posted

Frustration reigns among the workforce at the Legal Aid Society.

The union representing more than 1,000 workers at the Legal Aid Society announced a tentative agreement with management Wednesday without having had to resort to a work stoppage. Members of Legal Aid Society Attorneys United will vote on the agreement next week, but citing inadequate raises, a poorly executed bargaining strategy and the possibility of winning a better contract through a strike, many are urging their union colleagues to reject the pact. 

“I am of the opinion that our bargaining committee was more dedicated to averting a strike than it was to settling a contract on the best terms possible no matter what,” Jack Sorensen, a staff attorney at the Legal Aid Society and member of LASAU said Thursday. "It just kind of feels like we squandered this opportunity, but the good news is we can still vote to not ratify this contract. We're hoping for 51 percent of our members to vote no, which will put our bargaining committee in a position to move forward and secure the wins that they have a mandate from the membership to secure." 

‘Failed to meet the moment’ 

Attorneys, paralegals and support staff at over a dozen legal advocacy organizations across the city who belong to the Association of Legal Advocates and Attorneys aligned their contracts to expire this summer. Most units have reached tentative agreements that ended ongoing strikes or staved off impending walkouts, pending ratification by full union membership.  

Strikes at the Goddard Riverside Law Project, CAMBA Legal Services and the Urban Justice Center are ongoing, but after walkouts lasting several days, workers at New York Legal Assistance Group, Bronx Defenders and other organizations netted agreements with raises close to the union’s goals. 

But workers at the Legal Aid Society have watched as their union colleagues have won desired raises, workload protections and more following walkouts that ground some courts to a halt. Sorensen, who works in the Bronx, said that the strike at the Bronx Defenders forced his supervisors to take on work that striking attorneys vacated, and convinced him of the power that he and his colleagues could exercise — and the concessions that they could wring from management – if they went out on strike.  

But that strike never happened, and LASAU members have been peppering colleagues on the bargaining committee with questions and expressing their discontent in emails, online forums and, workers said, small workplace town halls since the agreement was announced. The mood in the ALAA's group email chain drastically changed from joking about the lavish spending of managers a week ago to members sharing denunciations of the LASAU bargaining committee and pleading with their colleagues to reject the agreement, according to screenshots shared with The Chief.

Under the tentative agreement, salaries of Legal Aid Society attorneys, who are currently the highest paid in the sector, would be surpassed by the salaries of workers at three other smaller organizations this year. Around 280 workers at NYLAG just reached a tentative agreement after five days on strike and the gap in salaries between LAS attorneys and those at NYLAG would grow in the next two fiscal years if both agreements are ratified. 

According to the tentative agreement, the LAS attorneys would get raises of 3 percent and 1.5 percent in fiscal years 2027 and 2028, respectively, while those at NYLAG would get 3.5 percent both years in a deal that will be voted on next week. 

“When I found out about [the tentative agreement] I was really disappointed. I thought the salaries were really low, I thought membership was ready to escalate,” said Ignacia Lolas Ojeda, a staff attorney in the Legal Aid Society’s parole revocation defense unit. “I think the bargaining committee failed to meet the moment.” 

Members of the Association of Legal Advocates and Attorneys at a strike rally in Foley Square earlier this month.
Members of the Association of Legal Advocates and Attorneys at a strike rally in Foley Square earlier this month.
Duncan Freeman / The Chief

Deadline delayed 

Lolas Ojeda first worried the union’s bargaining committee had run into trouble in early July when, she said, members of the committee stopped communicating with the contract action team, of which Lolas Ojeda is a member. That team’s goal was to organize and prepare workers for a strike. But about three weeks ago, “the bargaining committee just completely cut us out, they just completely stopped communicating with us," Lolas Ojeda said. 

That was just after workers authorized a strike with 91 percent support and rallied outside of the Legal Aid Society’s lower Manhattan office in a historic show of force. 

The union’s leadership set a strike deadline for July 25, a week after the contract’s July 18 expiration date which itself was over two weeks after its initial expiration date. Workers said the delay tempered the momentum they had built, including during a rowdy July 15 rally with Attorney General Letitia James and Assemblymember Zohran Mamdani. 

"There was a lot of momentum for us to go on strike,” said Alexis DiCarlo, a staff attorney who plans to vote no on the tentative agreement. "We should've gone on strike on July 18th." 

Jane Fox, the unit chair of LASAU and a member of the bargaining committee, did not reply to a request for a response to union members’ concerns. But a United Auto Workers official provided The Chief with a statement from Fox Wednesday evening in which the union leader said she was “proud to present this contract to our members to vote on.” 

Fox cited “historic gains” on workload protections, a student loan fund, 20 weeks of parental leave and retiree health benefits. But she expressed frustration with the financial aspects of the deal, saying the union was “fundamentally left behind by Mayor Adams and our employers on salaries and pensions.” 

“Our members will vote on this contract next week, but regardless if they do vote it up or down, we won a reopener guaranteeing no matter what, we will be back to win the salaries and pensions we deserve next year,” she said. 

‘Not over yet’ 

That reopener clause, which could allow the union to bargain over wages next year, has become a key aspect for meticulous members looking for reasons to support the agreement. Bronx Defenders’ strike this month occurred only because the union took advantage of a reopener clause tucked into their still-active contract, allowing them to make a wage proposal this year, which management rejected. 

Ratifying a contract this year that includes a reopener clause with the ability to strike could mean that Legal Aid Society workers would join other ALAA units with expiring contracts next year and fight for a wage increase in a fashion similar to how the Bronx Defenders did this summer. A reopener without a guarantee of the ability to strike could leave workers stuck with contract terms they’re unsatisfied with for the next three years.  

“Relying on an opener just speaks to the insulting nature of how much management is giving us and to how little the government is funding us,” said DiCarlo. “Many people are upset by this tentative agreement. I think a lot of people think it was prematurely made. I would not be surprised if 51 percent of membership was not happy with this contract and voted no."  

Twyla Carter, The Legal Aid Society’s attorney-in-chief and CEO, said in a statement when the agreement was announced that because of decades of state and city underfunding, workers’ pay has “not reflected the complexity or importance of their work.”

“While today’s development represents meaningful progress, we know that ensuring fair compensation and lasting support for our mission will require sustained investment from both Albany and City Hall,” she said of the agreement. “We look forward to partnering with ALAA as a united front in the fight to secure the resources that both honor the vital contributions of our staff attorneys and support the long-term sustainability of a career at Legal Aid.” 

A union town hall at which members can ask questions about the contract has been scheduled for early next week, workers said. The ratification vote will take place after that. 

Sorensen has already made his decision on how to vote.  

"Everybody understands there were missteps made and where we go from now is we have to not ratify this contract so we can get back to the bargaining table,” he said. "It's not over yet." 

hfreeman@thechiefleader.com

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here